Do auto repair shops get their Google Maps spot back on Monday? Three mornings in 11 cities
We searched Google Maps for auto repair in 11 US cities on Saturday, Sunday and Monday at the same hour. The six-day shops that fell out on Sunday mostly stayed out, and Monday looked like Sunday, not Saturday.
Yesterday’s study found that a shop closed on Sunday mostly left the Sunday map pack, or fell about five places if it stayed. Whether that matters depends on whether the loss lasts. One belief is that Google’s ranking has memory: a listing that drops out of the pack takes days to climb back, so a weekend closure costs the start of the week as well. The other is that the open state at the minute of the search is the whole mechanism, so on Monday morning, when six-day and five-day shops are all open, every shop returns to where it sat on Saturday and the five-day shops give back their Sunday gain.
Neither happened. The six-day shops did not come back, and the five-day shops gave nothing back. Monday’s pack looked like Sunday’s with the doors open, not like Saturday’s.
On Saturday, October 31, 2026, at 9:26 in the morning Eastern, we searched Google Maps for “auto repair” plus the city in 11 US cities, 6 large metros and 5 small cities, 20 listings each. We searched again on Sunday at 9:21 and on Monday, November 2, at 9:29, so the three searches sit within eight minutes of the same local hour. Every listing was matched to itself across the three days by Google place id. The same three searches ran for the word “mechanic” one minute behind, as a second sample with its own dataset.
Three mornings, three different packs
By Saturday’s open state and Sunday’s listed hours, the 220 Saturday listings split into 72 six-day shops (open at Saturday’s search, closed Sunday), 112 five-day shops (closed at both weekend searches) and 34 seven-day shops (open both). On Monday, 218 of the 219 listings with hours were open, so Monday is the first of the three mornings on which the open state separates nobody.
| Saturday’s 220 auto repair listings | Six-day shops | Five-day shops | Seven-day shops |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listings on Saturday | 72 | 112 | 34 |
| Median reviews | 290 | 246 | 422 |
| Chain locations | 10 | 5 | 12 |
| Still in the top 20 on Sunday | 29 | 110 | 26 |
| Still in the top 20 on Monday | 38 | 102 | 14 |
| Left Sunday, back Monday | 9 | 0 | 1 |
| Saturday to Monday move, shops in both | down 4 | up 2 | down 7 |
| Top-three slots Saturday, Sunday, Monday | 14, 4, 7 | 13, 22, 26 | 6, 7, 0 |
| Position 1 Saturday, Sunday, Monday | 7, 1, 2 | 4, 6, 9 | 0, 4, 0 |
The six-day shops did not come back
Of the 43 six-day shops that left the Sunday top 20, 9 were back on Monday and 34 were not. The 9 that returned did not return to their places: they had sat at a median position of 9 on Saturday and sat at 19 on Monday, 8 of the 9 lower than Saturday. The 29 six-day shops that had survived Sunday were all still listed on Monday and recovered a median of 2 places from Sunday. Measured against Saturday, though, the 38 six-day shops in Monday’s pack sat 4 places lower, at a median position of 10 against 5, with 33 down, 1 up and 4 unchanged, and only 15 within two places of their Saturday position. Their 14 Saturday top-three slots became 4 on Sunday and 7 on Monday.
The fall held in every review third: the 7 least-reviewed six-day shops in Monday’s pack were down 3 from Saturday, the 11 in the middle third down 7, and the 20 most reviewed down 3. Volume did not buy a return.
In the 6 metros the six-day shops numbered 55; 33 left on Sunday, 8 of those were back on Monday at a median position of 19, 25 were still gone, and the 30 in Monday’s pack sat 3 places below Saturday, 10 against 5. In the 5 small cities the six-day shops numbered 17; 10 left on Sunday, 1 came back, and all 8 in Monday’s pack were lower than on Saturday, by a median of 8 places, from 5 to 15. Their 4 Saturday top-three slots became 0 on Sunday and 2 on Monday.
Monday looks like Sunday
Monday’s 220 listings were 155 shops from Saturday’s pack, 32 that had entered on Sunday and stayed, and 33 that were in neither weekend pack: weekday shops, several with hundreds of reviews, shut on both weekend mornings while open competitors filled the list. The rank correlation between a shop’s position on two days was 0.516 for Saturday against Monday and 0.77 for Sunday against Monday, and of the 33 top-three slots, 20 were held by the same business on Saturday and Monday, 26 on Sunday and Monday.
The five-day shops explain it. Closed at Saturday’s search and sitting at a median position of 11, they rose on Sunday when everyone was closed, and rose again on Monday when everyone was open: the 102 in Monday’s pack sat at a median position of 7, 2 places above Saturday, with 71 up, 11 down and 20 unchanged. Their 13 Saturday top-three slots had become 22 on Sunday and were 26 on Monday, and they held position 1 in 9 of 11 cities, against 4 on Saturday. In the metros the five-day shops gained 4 places from Saturday to Monday, from 11 to 6; in the small cities 2, from 10 to 7.
The one Monday listing not open at the search is the mechanism in miniature. A small-city shop that opens one minute after the search ran had sat at 10 on Saturday and 8 on Sunday. On Monday, the only closed listing in a pack of open ones, it sat at 18.
The seven-day shops lost the most
The 34 shops open on both weekend mornings, 12 of them chain locations, had the most reviews of the three groups. On Monday 14 of them were still in the top 20, and those 14 had fallen a median of 7 places, from 4 to 13, all 14 down. Their 6 Saturday and 7 Sunday top-three slots became 0 on Monday, and the 4 cities where a seven-day shop held position 1 on Sunday all changed hands. Being open while competitors were closed had carried them on both weekend mornings. With everyone open on Monday, the pack put them at the bottom.
Your benchmark
Search “auto repair” plus your city on a Saturday, a Sunday and a Monday morning at the same hour, and note the three positions. The Monday number is the one to compare with your competitors, because it is the only one of the three on which nobody was open while you were closed, or closed while you were open.
If you are open six days, expect your Saturday position to run about 4 places above your Monday position, and about half of the six-day shops in a Saturday pack are not in the Monday pack at all: 34 of 72 here. If you are open five days, your Saturday search understates you by about 2 places, and Monday morning is your best day: five-day shops held 26 of 33 Monday top-three slots. If you are open seven days, the weekend mornings are your days; on Monday the seven-day shops in this sample held none of the 33.
The mechanic pack said the same
The “mechanic” searches gave a second sample with more weekend openers. Of its 74 six-day shops, 51 left on Sunday, 13 came back on Monday at a median position of 16 against 8 on Saturday, and 38 were still gone; the 35 in Monday’s pack sat 5 places below Saturday, 11 against 5. Its 90 five-day shops had 88 in Monday’s pack, 3 places above Saturday, and their top-three slots went from 10 on Saturday to 19 on Sunday to 27 on Monday. Its 49 seven-day shops, 13 of them chains, had 19 left on Monday, down 6 places from 4 to 13, and their 10 Saturday and 11 Sunday top-three slots were 0 on Monday. Monday’s mechanic pack was 142 shops from Saturday, 35 from Sunday only and 42 new, with rank correlations of 0.387 against Saturday and 0.743 against Sunday.
The ladder underneath did not change. Position against review count was rho -0.238 on Saturday, -0.248 on Sunday and -0.25 on Monday in the auto repair pack, and -0.206, -0.281 and -0.355 in the mechanic pack. The open state moved shops up and down the ladder for a morning; it did not change what the ladder was made of.
Limits
This is three mornings in 11 cities, 220 listings a day, matched by place id; the searches ran at 9:26, 9:21 and 9:29 Eastern, so the comparison holds the local hour to within eight minutes and says nothing about an afternoon or evening pack. Three days cannot separate memory from reversion: a six-day shop that sits lower on Monday than on Saturday may be paying for Sunday, or Saturday may have been the anomaly, and only a second Saturday would tell them apart. The Sunday-to-Monday recovery of 2 places for the six-day shops that stayed, against a Saturday-to-Monday loss of 4, is consistent with either. We did not measure how many people search on each morning, so we cannot say what a Saturday position is worth against a Monday one.
The groups are defined by listed hours and by Google’s open state at one minute, not by verified hours. Measuring only shops that already rank cannot say what separates them from shops that rank on none of the three days. No listing was excluded from the Monday auto repair results, and one from the mechanic results, a national lead marketplace’s own city listing, as on the two earlier days; the screen is the Saturday screen, unchanged. The metro and small-city figures rest on 6 and 5 cities, the small-city six-day group is 17 shops, and the seven-day group is 34. The six-day group’s median review count over all 72 shops is 290; yesterday’s article gave 504, which described the 29 that stayed in the Sunday pack, and the 38 in Monday’s pack also carry a median of 504. The three-day matching was added to the engine for this study and recomputed from the saved Monday search with no new searches; the Sunday-to-Monday counts were identical before and after. Both packs ship as datasets, with every Saturday listing’s three positions in the three-day rows.
The data behind this article
Check it yourself.
Every figure above comes from the dataset below, captured . Rows that were screened out of the analysis are included, each with the reason it was excluded, because that screening decision changes findings more often than the analysis does.
Free to reuse with attribution to Ultimate Analytics and a link to this article. If you rerun the analysis and reach a different answer, we would like to know.
Related
For operators
"Tree removal" or "tree service": does Google Maps show the same companies?
Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 192 of 210 tree companies appeared for both words and the top three barely moved. The same word a week apart changed the list almost as much.
For operators
Can a suburb address rank on Google Maps in the city next door? 549 city lists in 25 trades
Listings with an address in another town were 13 percent of Google Maps results and held 4 percent of top-three slots. At the same review count they sat 2 to 7 places lower.
For operators
"Realtor" or "real estate agent": does Google Maps show the same agents?
Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 175 of 217 listings appeared for both words, fewer than the same search repeated 18 days later. Individual agents lost the most.