"Tree removal" or "tree service": does Google Maps show the same companies?
Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 192 of 210 tree companies appeared for both words and the top three barely moved. The same word a week apart changed the list almost as much.
Tree company owners are often told that “tree removal” is its own search. The customer with a dead oak over the garage types “tree removal,” the advice goes, Google shows a different set of companies for it, and a company that wants those calls has to put “removal” in its listing name. The opposite view is that Google reads both phrases as one request and shows the same twenty companies either way. We searched both in the same cities, one minute apart, and counted who showed up.
On Friday, November 20, 2026, a little after 9 in the morning Eastern, we searched Google Maps for “tree service” plus the city in 11 US cities, 6 large metros and 5 small cities. One minute later we searched the same 11 cities for “tree removal.” Each search returned 20 listings, 220 per phrase. Both packs went through the same screen, which removed tree farms and nurseries, lawn care and landscaping companies that do not present as tree companies, a mulching listing, and keyword-named listings we could not confirm as businesses. It excluded 10 results from the tree service pack and 11 from the tree removal pack, leaving 210 and 209 companies, matched to each other by Google place id.
We also had a yardstick. One week earlier, on Friday, November 13, at the same hour, we had searched “tree service” in the same cities. Comparing that list with this week’s shows how much the map changes when the words do not change at all.
The finding
227 distinct companies appeared across the two packs. 192 appeared for both phrases, 18 only for “tree service” and 17 only for “tree removal.” That is 91 percent of the tree service pack still there when the phrase changed.
The same phrase a week apart kept 199 of 209, or 95 percent. So changing the phrase moved the list a little more than seven days did, and not by much.
At the top there was no difference at all between the two comparisons. All 33 companies in a top three for “tree service” were in the pack for “tree removal,” at a median position of 2. The same company held 29 of the 33 top-three slots for both phrases, and the same company held position 1 in 9 of 11 cities. The week-apart comparison gave the identical figures: 29 of 33 and 9 of 11. In the two cities where position 1 changed with the phrase, Charlotte and Tampa, the new leader came from the other phrase’s top three.
The turnover was at the bottom. Of the 108 companies in a top ten for “tree service,” 107 reappeared for “tree removal.” Of the 102 at positions 11 to 20, 85 did; a week apart, 92 of 101 did. The companies that appeared for only one phrase sat at a median position of 19 and 18, and none was in a top three.
For scale, we have run this design in four other trades. The share of the pack that carried over was 74 percent for “auto repair” and “mechanic,” 81 percent for “real estate agent” and “realtor,” 87 percent for “plumber” and “plumbing,” and 94 percent for “personal injury lawyer” and “attorney.” Tree work, at 91 percent, sits near the steady end.
Your benchmark
Search “tree service” plus your city, then “tree removal” plus your city, within a few minutes of each other. Note your position in each, then compare with the table. The “one week apart” rows are the change to expect from nothing.
| All 11 cities | 6 large metros | 5 small cities | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tree service pack still there for “tree removal” | 192 of 210 | 107 of 120 | 85 of 90 |
| Share | 91 percent | 89 percent | 94 percent |
| Same phrase, one week apart | 199 of 209 | 111 of 120 | 88 of 89 |
| Share | 95 percent | 93 percent | 99 percent |
| Top-three slots held by the same company, two phrases | 29 of 33 | 15 of 18 | 14 of 15 |
| Top-three slots held by the same company, one week apart | 29 of 33 | 16 of 18 | 13 of 15 |
| In both packs, moved five places or more | 17 | 10 | 7 |
| Rank correlation between the two phrases | 0.899 | 0.875 | 0.931 |
If you are in a top ten for one phrase, expect to be in the pack for the other; only one company here was not. If you sit below position 10 and appear for one phrase only, that happened to about one company in six, and a week of ordinary change does half of that by itself. For reference, the median listing in the tree service pack carried 135 reviews in the metros and 21 in the small cities.
The word in the name: a nudge, not a gate
Ten companies across the two packs had “removal” in the listing name. Eight appeared for both phrases. Two appeared only for “tree removal,” both at position 18. None appeared only for “tree service.”
Among the eight that appeared for both, six sat higher for “tree removal” than for “tree service,” by one to seven places, two held the same position, and none sat lower. The other companies in both packs split about evenly between moving up and moving down. As a control, we followed the same eight across the week with the phrase unchanged: three moved up, three moved down and two stayed put.
That is a pattern on a very small count. A “removal” name may be worth a few places for that phrase. It is not required: of 143 companies with “service” in the name, 119 appeared for both phrases, 13 only for “tree service” and 11 only for “tree removal.”
Reviews did not decide who carried over
In the plumbing study, thinly reviewed companies were the ones that appeared for one word only. Here they were not. Splitting all 227 companies into thirds by review count, 84 percent of the least reviewed third appeared in both packs, against 85 percent of the middle third and 85 percent of the most reviewed third.
The metros showed a slope: 73, 82 and 89 percent from the least to the most reviewed third. The small cities did not: 89, 90 and 90 percent. All 13 national brand locations appeared for both phrases.
Which city churned depended on the day more than the phrase. Chicago kept 16 of 20 between the two phrases and Houston 17 of 20. Across the week with the phrase unchanged, Houston kept 20 of 20 and Nashville only 15 of 20.
What verification found
The numbers did not change in verification this time, so here is what was checked. We compared the excluded listings of the two packs by place id: no listing was excluded from one pack and kept in the other, the error that distorted our first pass on plumbers. Google filed 207 of the 210 kept tree service listings first under Tree service; two led with Arborist service, and one stump grinder led with Landscaper and was kept on its name.
Two things are left in the data and described, not removed. One name appears on three listings in Chicago and Nashville that show no website, list 24-hour opening and carry 6 to 10 reviews; a fourth listing with the “removal” variant of that name and 2 reviews appeared only for “tree removal.” We could not confirm them or rule them out. And one Bismarck company holds two listings that point to the same website, in both packs; they count as two.
What to do with it
Check both phrases once. If you are near the top for one, you are near the top for the other, and there is no separate “tree removal” map to win. If you are in the bottom half of the list, expect to drop in and out, with or without a change of phrase. For a new listing, “removal” in a true business name may earn a few places for that phrase; eight listings do not justify renaming an established company.
Limits
This is one morning in 11 cities, and it measures who appears, not who gets the call. We captured only the top 20, so a company missing from one pack may sit just outside it. Searches were not run from a device inside each city, and results on a phone near the customer will differ. The week-apart yardstick shares this morning’s tree service search with the two-phrase comparison, so the two are not independent. The name finding rests on ten companies and the brand finding on 13 locations; both are counts, not tests. November is the off season for tree work in the northern cities, and a storm week could reorder a list. “Tree trimming,” “stump grinding” and “emergency tree removal” were not searched. Measuring only companies that already appear cannot say what separates them from those that never do. Every listing in both packs, including the excluded ones with their reasons, is in the dataset, and the tree service pack with its week-earlier comparison is published beside it at /data/tree-service-query-maps/.
The data behind this article
Check it yourself.
Every figure above comes from the dataset below, captured . Rows that were screened out of the analysis are included, each with the reason it was excluded, because that screening decision changes findings more often than the analysis does.
Free to reuse with attribution to Ultimate Analytics and a link to this article. If you rerun the analysis and reach a different answer, we would like to know.
Related
For operators
Can a suburb address rank on Google Maps in the city next door? 549 city lists in 25 trades
Listings with an address in another town were 13 percent of Google Maps results and held 4 percent of top-three slots. At the same review count they sat 2 to 7 places lower.
For operators
"Realtor" or "real estate agent": does Google Maps show the same agents?
Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 175 of 217 listings appeared for both words, fewer than the same search repeated 18 days later. Individual agents lost the most.
For operators
Do restoration franchises own Google Maps for water damage? 365 listings in 22 cities
National restoration brands hold 29 of 66 top-three Google Maps slots for water damage, in small cities as in metros. At equal review counts, a brand sits where an independent does.