Can a suburb address rank on Google Maps in the city next door? 549 city lists in 25 trades
Listings with an address in another town were 13 percent of Google Maps results and held 4 percent of top-three slots. At the same review count they sat 2 to 7 places lower.
Owners based in a suburb hear a comforting plan: keep collecting reviews, and your listing will work its way into the Google Maps results for the big city next door. Reviews are the lever, the belief goes, and the address is a detail.
Yesterday’s window cleaning study pointed the other way on one list. So we asked the question of every list this series has captured on one set of 22 US cities: twenty-five trades and professions, 11 large metros and 11 small cities, captured between September 29 and November 18, 2026. That is 549 trade-by-city lists and 9,610 listings after each source study’s screen (1,071 excluded results stay in the dataset with their reasons). No new searches were run.
The short answer: the belief is wrong in most cities. A listing whose address is in another town sat lower than an in-city listing with the same review count, in every trade where we could compare, and almost never reached the top three.
Your benchmark
We read the town on every address line. Of the 9,610 listings, 7,387 (77 percent) showed an address in the city searched, 1,242 (13 percent) showed an address in another town, and 977 (10 percent) hid the address. Four could not be read.
The out-of-town listings were not the weak ones. Their median review count was 119, against 93 for in-city listings. Their median position was 13, against 9.
They also thin out toward the top. Listings from another town were 18 percent of positions 13 to 20, 14 percent of positions 8 to 12, 10 percent of positions 4 to 7 and 4 percent of the top three: 70 of 1,612 slots. They held first place on 15 of 544 lists. At least one appeared somewhere on 359 of the 549 lists, and one reached the top three on 60.
To check your own market, search your trade and the city you want, and read the town on each of the top three address lines.
Same reviews, lower position
We split each trade’s address-showing listings into thirds by review count, separately for metros and small cities, then compared the two groups inside each third.
| Median position | Address in the city | Address in another town |
|---|---|---|
| Least reviewed third | 12 | 14 |
| Middle third | 8 | 13 |
| Most reviewed third | 5 | 12 |
The gap is 2, 5 and 7 places, widest among the most reviewed. There, in-city listings (349 reviews at the median) sat at position 5 and out-of-town listings (408 reviews) sat at 12. More reviews went with a much higher position for in-city listings and barely a higher one for out-of-town listings.
Small cities showed it more sharply than metros: 12 against 14, 7 against 13 and 4 against 12 in small cities, and 13 against 15, 9 against 13 and 6 against 12 in metros.
Find your trade
Only trades with at least 10 out-of-town listings can be compared. In metros that was 20 trades: the out-of-town group had the lower median position in 18, was level in 2 (roofing and handyman) and was higher in none. In small cities it was 17 trades, and the out-of-town group sat lower in all 17, by 3 to 9 places.
| Trade | Metros: share from another town | Metro top-three slots they held | Metro median position, in city against another town | Small cities: share from another town |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Junk removal | 29% | 4 of 33 | 8 against 13 | 21% |
| Window cleaning | 28% | 4 of 33 | 8 against 13 | 17% |
| Garage door repair | 25% | 6 of 33 | 10 against 13 | 36% |
| Handyman | 24% | 3 of 33 | 9 against 9 | 15% |
| Water damage restoration | 23% | 4 of 33 | 10 against 13 | 24% |
| Managed IT services | 22% | 5 of 33 | 10 against 12 | 16% |
| Carpet cleaning | 21% | 4 of 32 | 9 against 14 | 11% |
| Pest control | 19% | 0 of 32 | 9 against 14 | 26% |
| Moving | 18% | 3 of 33 | 9 against 12 | 16% |
| Tree service | 18% | 1 of 33 | 9 against 14 | 17% |
| Roofing | 17% | 3 of 33 | 10 against 10 | 9% |
| Appliance repair | 16% | 3 of 33 | 9 against 13 | 21% |
| Landscaping | 16% | 3 of 33 | 10 against 11 | 8% |
| House cleaning | 15% | 2 of 33 | 10 against 13 | 11% |
| Chiropractors | 15% | 3 of 33 | 10 against 13 | 3% |
| Locksmiths | 14% | 1 of 33 | 9 against 14 | 14% |
| Pet groomers | 10% | 1 of 33 | 10 against 12 | 16% |
| HVAC | 9% | 0 of 33 | 9 against 13 | 8% |
Seven trades are missing from the table because the question barely arises: dentists, hair salons, physical therapy, accountants, insurance agencies, personal injury lawyers and real estate agents. In each, out-of-town listings were at most 7 percent of the list in either market size, and they held no top-three slot anywhere.
What verification found: three cities carry the exceptions
The first pass gave one pooled figure for metros: out-of-town listings held 50 of 816 top-three slots, 6 percent. Reading the towns city by city changed how that number should be read.
Thirty-seven of those 50 slots, and 11 of the 14 metro first places, were in three cities: Detroit, Milwaukee and St. Louis. There, out-of-town listings were 34, 31 and 20 percent of the list. The towns on those address lines are close-in suburbs that border the city, and a large share of each trade is based in them.
In the other eight metros, out-of-town listings held 13 of 594 top-three slots, 2 percent, and 3 of 199 first places. In Charlotte, Nashville and Chicago they held none.
The gap inside review thirds did not depend on those three cities. Inside them it was 2, 4 and 5 places. In the other eight metros it was 2, 3 and 7.
What it took to get in from outside differed, though. In the eight ordinary metros, the out-of-town listings that reached a top three carried a median of 841 reviews, 6.62 times the median for their own list. In-city listings in the same top threes carried 410, or 1.93 times. In small cities the 20 out-of-town listings that reached a top three were not review giants (a median of 62 reviews, against 103 for in-city listings there), and with 20 of them we cannot say what set them apart.
What to do with this
- Read the town on each address line in the top three for the city you want. If every one is in that city, expect the same rule to apply to you.
- If your address is in another town, reviews alone are a slow road into the neighboring city. In most metros the few that made it carried several times the review count of the typical listing.
- Put the effort where your address works for you. The same data says an in-city address is worth 2 to 7 places at equal reviews, and in your own town that is your advantage.
- Do not list an address you do not staff. This study measures position, not the risk of a suspension.
Limits
- Twenty-five snapshots, taken on twenty-five different days at different hours. The lists are not one moment.
- Only businesses already in the top 20 are measured. Out-of-town businesses that never appear on a neighboring city’s list are not counted, so the out-of-town group here is the part of it that got through.
- “In the city” means the postal town on the address line matches the city searched, not the legal city limit. Some neighborhoods carry their own postal name (Nashville’s list includes a few) and are counted as another town.
- The 977 hidden-address listings show no town and are left out of every comparison.
- A shared city name pulls in listings from other states (Rochester is one). They are counted as another town, which they are.
- Every search named the city and ran from a server. A search from a phone may behave differently.
- The chain tag and the exclusion screen are each source study’s own, and are not uniform across trades.
- This is correlation in one set of 22 cities. Review counts were held roughly constant; distance in miles, service areas set on the profile and the age of the listing were not measured here.
The data behind this article
Check it yourself.
Every figure above comes from the dataset below, captured . Rows that were screened out of the analysis are included, each with the reason it was excluded, because that screening decision changes findings more often than the analysis does.
Free to reuse with attribution to Ultimate Analytics and a link to this article. If you rerun the analysis and reach a different answer, we would like to know.
Related
For operators
"Tree removal" or "tree service": does Google Maps show the same companies?
Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 192 of 210 tree companies appeared for both words and the top three barely moved. The same word a week apart changed the list almost as much.
For operators
"Realtor" or "real estate agent": does Google Maps show the same agents?
Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 175 of 217 listings appeared for both words, fewer than the same search repeated 18 days later. Individual agents lost the most.
For operators
Do restoration franchises own Google Maps for water damage? 365 listings in 22 cities
National restoration brands hold 29 of 66 top-three Google Maps slots for water damage, in small cities as in metros. At equal review counts, a brand sits where an independent does.