Talk about a build

For operators 2026-11-03 6 min

Does being close to the city center help you rank on Google Maps? Four trades, 22 cities

We measured 1,690 Google Maps top-20 listings in four trades and 22 cities. The top three almost always sit in the city searched, but only pest control is ordered by distance.

Ultimate Analytics

Local search advice leans hard on proximity. Be near the middle of the city, the advice goes, and Google will put you ahead of a competitor farther out; sit in the next town over and you will not reach the top three for the city your customers live in. Two earlier studies in this series disagreed with each other. Painters showed no ordering by distance. Pest control showed a strong one. We could not tell whether proximity is a rule of Google Maps or a property of the trade.

So we ran the same measurement on four trades searched in the same 22 US cities, 11 large metros and 11 small cities: pest control, personal injury lawyers, chiropractors and real estate agents. That is 1,759 results and 1,690 businesses after each source study’s own exclusions, in 88 trade-by-city lists, captured on four days between October 22 and October 29, 2026. No new searches were spent. Every row comes from a dataset already published, and each address was read the same way: is it in the city searched, and how many miles is it from that city’s center.

The short answer is that proximity is two different things. As a filter it is close to universal: 256 of the 261 top-three listings with a street address were in the city searched, and position 1 was in the city in all 88 lists. As an ordering inside the list it belongs to one trade of the four. Pest control sorted by distance (rank correlation 0.391); personal injury lawyers (0.008), chiropractors (0.077) and real estate agents (0.061) did not. In all four trades, review count ordered the list.

Your benchmark

Look up your own street address, measure the miles to the center of your city, and compare it with the top three in your trade. The columns below are medians across all 22 cities. A positive correlation means listings farther from the center sit lower on the list.

Trade Listings In the city searched Top three in the city Median miles, top three Median miles, positions 13 to 20 Miles vs. rank correlation Reviews vs. rank correlation
Pest control 388 76% 97% 3.4 8.7 0.391 -0.154
Personal injury lawyers 431 98% 100% 0.7 0.7 0.008 -0.252
Chiropractors 438 91% 95% 3.2 3.5 0.077 -0.408
Real estate agents 433 96% 100% 2.1 2.7 0.061 -0.291

The in-city columns count listings with a street address only. Miles use street addresses too, and the 1,650 that qualify have a median of 2.8 miles from the center. The distance correlation was significant in one trade of four. The review correlation was significant in all four.

The city line is a filter

Of the 1,649 listings with a street address, 1,497 (91 percent) were in the city searched. The 152 that were not sat at a median position of 14, against 10 for those in the city. Only 5 of them reached the top three: two pest control companies in towns next to Wausau, 4.4 miles out, and three chiropractors in suburbs of Detroit and St. Louis. None held position 1.

So the belief that a business outside the city struggles for a search naming the city is mostly right, and it is also mostly invisible, because few businesses outside the line make the list at all. This study sees only the inside of the filter. It cannot say how many suburban businesses were kept off the list.

Only pest control is a circle

Pest control is the one trade where distance behaved like an ordering. Across the 353 street addresses, the top three sat a median 3.4 miles from the center against 8.7 for positions 13 to 20. It held in metros (correlation 0.209) and more strongly in small cities (0.523), where all the top-three street addresses were within 10 miles, a median 2.1, while positions 13 to 20 sat a median 12.8 miles out. It also held inside review thirds: in small cities all three thirds were significant, and in metros two of three.

Pest control is also the trade whose map listings are least tied to an office. 24 percent of its addressed listings were outside the city searched, against 2 to 9 percent in the other three, and 32 of 388 hid the address entirely, as service-area businesses can. Those hidden-address listings sat at a median position of 14 with a median 38 reviews, against 230 for the rest. A trade where the address is a garage, a home or a depot has more room for distance to matter, and room is what the other three trades lack.

The office trades are not ordered by miles

Personal injury lawyers are the clearest case of nothing to sort. The median listing was 0.7 miles from the center and so was the median of positions 13 to 20: firms cluster near the courthouse, and a list of businesses all within a few blocks cannot be ordered by miles. That is a ceiling on the measurement, not a finding about Google.

Chiropractors and real estate agents are a stronger test, because they spread out. The median chiropractor in a large metro sat 5.3 miles from the center, and 15 percent were more than 10 miles out. Distance still did not order the metro list (correlation 0.121, not significant), and inside review thirds none of the three metro tests cleared the bar. Real estate agents were the same: 0.102 in metros, 0 of 3 thirds. In-city status was weakly related to rank for chiropractors (correlation -0.111, in the city at a median position of 10 against 13 for the 38 outside it) and not for agents or lawyers.

Not significant is not no effect. With 217 to 438 listings per trade, a small proximity effect in these three trades could hide, and the review effect is the one this sample can see clearly.

Reviews order every list

In all four trades, position against review count was negative and significant: pest control -0.154, personal injury lawyers -0.252, real estate agents -0.291 and chiropractors -0.408. In small-city chiropractic it reached -0.684. Distance reached significance in one trade, and the in-city flag in two. If you can only move one number, the one that orders every list is the number of people who have reviewed you.

What this means on Monday

Check that your listing’s address is in the city you want to rank for. A suburb address is the one proximity penalty this sample shows in every trade: a median 14 against 10. If you are in pest control or another service-area trade, measure your miles from the center against the top three in your market size; in a small city, 2.1 miles is the median for the top three. If you are an office trade, do not spend a week moving or arguing about the address. Once you are inside the city, this sample finds no ordering by miles that a business could use, and reviews carry the list.

Limits

  • Four snapshots taken on four different days between October 22 and October 29, 2026, on different weekdays and at different hours. The lists are not a single moment.
  • Only businesses already in the top 20 are measured, so nothing here says what it takes to get onto the list, only how the listed ones are arranged. A distance effect could work almost entirely at the point of entry.
  • Distance is measured from a geocoded point for each city’s center to the street address Google showed, and the same 22 points were used for all four trades. A city’s center is a convention, not where its searchers are. Hidden-address listings are reported on their own, because their pin is Google’s, not the business’s.
  • Every search named the city in the query. This measures a city-named search, not a search for the trade near me from a phone, where the searcher’s own location matters and was not varied.
  • The trades differ in more than their willingness to sort by distance. Spread of addresses, share of chains and how many businesses compete all differ, and four trades cannot separate those from a Google rule. Painters, searched on a different city list, are not included.
  • The chain or organization tag is each source study’s own definition and is not uniform across trades.

The data behind this article

Check it yourself.

Every figure above comes from the dataset below, captured . Rows that were screened out of the analysis are included, each with the reason it was excluded, because that screening decision changes findings more often than the analysis does.

Free to reuse with attribution to Ultimate Analytics and a link to this article. If you rerun the analysis and reach a different answer, we would like to know.

Find out what your marketing
is actually achieving.

One conversation, no obligation: what you sell, who you lose deals to, and what you cannot currently see. If a build is a fit, it is scoped and quoted from there. There is no signup and no self-serve tier.

No prices on this site. Every engagement is scoped and quoted after the first meeting.