Does closing on Sunday cost an auto repair shop its Google Maps spot? 11 cities, Saturday against Sunday
We searched Google Maps for auto repair in 11 US cities on Saturday morning and again on Sunday at the same local hour. Six-day shops lost their Saturday position or left the pack; five-day shops moved up.
Shop owners hear two things about Sunday. One is that Google favors the listing that is open when someone searches, so a shop that closes on Sunday drops down or out of the Sunday map pack while the chains, quick-lube stores and mobile mechanics that work Sundays take its place. The other is that Sunday hours are a staffing decision and nothing more, because nearly every shop in the trade is closed and Google has no open competitor to promote. Both camps agree that what matters is whether you are open on Sunday. The data says the thing that matters is whether you were open on Saturday.
On Saturday, October 31, 2026, at 9:26 in the morning Eastern, we searched Google Maps for “auto repair” plus the city in 11 US cities, 6 large metros and 5 small cities, 20 listings each. On Sunday, November 1, we searched the same 11 cities again. The clocks changed overnight, so the second search ran 55 minutes later by the universal clock and five minutes earlier by the local one, at 9:21 Eastern. Every listing was matched to itself across the two days by Google place id. We ran the same pair of searches for the word “mechanic” one minute behind, as a second sample with its own dataset, and it told the same story.
Three kinds of shop
By their listed hours, 184 of the 218 Saturday listings with hours close all day Sunday. At Saturday’s search minute, 106 were open and 112 were closed, and the closed ones were almost all shops that do not open on Saturday at all. That splits the Saturday pack into three groups an owner can place themselves in: shops open six days (open at Saturday’s search, closed Sunday), shops open five days (closed at both searches), and shops open seven days (open on both).
| Saturday’s 220 auto repair listings | Six-day shops | Five-day shops | Seven-day shops |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listings on Saturday | 72 | 112 | 34 |
| Median reviews | 504 | 248 | 518 |
| Median Saturday position | 4 | 11 | 9 |
| Left the top 20 by Sunday | 43 | 2 | 8 |
| Median move for those that stayed | down 5 | up 1 | up 2 |
| Saturday top-three slots | 14 | 13 | 6 |
| Sunday top-three slots | 4 | 22 | 7 |
The six-day shops are the established ones: the most reviews, the best Saturday positions. On Sunday 43 of the 72 were gone from the top 20 entirely, 14 of them from a Saturday top ten, and the 29 that stayed fell a median of 5 places, from a median position of 4 to 10, with 23 down, 1 up and 5 unchanged. Their 14 top-three slots became 4.
The five-day shops did the opposite. They had sat lower on Saturday, at a median position of 11, because they were closed while the six-day shops were open. On Sunday everyone was closed, and they rose a median of 1 place: 69 up, 19 down, 22 unchanged, and only 2 of 112 left the list. Every one of their 13 Saturday top-three slots held, and they picked up 9 more, to 22 of 33. The Sunday pack is, mostly, a list of shops that were closed on Saturday morning too.
The seven-day shops gained, but less than the belief promises. 8 of 34 left the list, and the 26 that stayed rose a median of 2, from 9 to 7. The 21 that were open at Sunday’s search minute rose 4, from 10 to 5, with 17 up and 3 down; the 5 that list Sunday hours but had not yet opened at 9:21 fell 6. Being open Sunday bought a few places. It did not buy the pack: 26 of the 33 Sunday top-three slots went to shops that were closed at the moment of the search.
The rank correlation between a shop’s change in open state across the two searches and its change in position was 0.614 on 165 matched listings, 0.56 on independents alone, and 0.596 on 150 in the mechanic pack. Inside review thirds the six-day shops that stayed fell 8, 4 and 4 places from the least to the most reviewed third, so volume softened the fall and did not prevent it.
Your benchmark
Search “auto repair” plus your city on a Saturday morning and again on Sunday at the same local hour, and note both positions. If you are open six days, the Saturday number is the one Sunday cannot keep: a six-day shop that stayed in the Sunday pack fell a median of 5 places, and 43 of 72 did not stay. If you are open five days, Sunday is your better day, by about a place, and 2 of 112 left the list. If you are open seven days and the door is open when the search runs, expect to sit about 4 places above your Saturday position.
The size of the move follows the size of the market. In the 6 metros the six-day shops numbered 55: 33 left and the 22 that stayed fell 5, from 4 to 10. The 11 seven-day shops open at Sunday’s minute rose 6, from 11 to 5. In the 5 small cities the six-day shops numbered 17: 10 left, all 7 that stayed fell, by a median of 6, from 2 to 9, and their 4 Saturday top-three slots became none. Small-city seven-day shops, 10 of the 18 of them chains, did not move: the 14 that stayed went from a median of 8 to 11.
Who is open on a Sunday morning
34 of the 216 Sunday listings with hours were open at the search: 10 chain locations, 8 mobile mechanics by name, 7 independents listed as open 24 hours and 9 other independents with Sunday hours. The chains sat at a median position of 12 and held 1 top-three slot; the 24-hour listings held 3, all in small cities, where the 4 of them sat at a median position of 2 on a median 19 reviews.
Position 1 changed hands in 7 of 11 cities. Of the 7 six-day shops that held position 1 on Saturday, one still held it on Sunday, a shop with 1,077 reviews, and the other six sat between 3 and 9. Of the 4 five-day shops that held position 1 on Saturday, three still held it and one sat at 2. An open shop took position 1 in 4 cities: a mobile mechanic with 194 reviews that had sat at 5 on Saturday, an independent with 831 reviews that had sat at 9, a national tire chain’s store that had sat at 2, and in one small city a listing open 24 hours with 16 reviews that had sat at 5.
The mechanic pack said the same
The “mechanic” search gave a second sample with more Sunday openers, because mobile mechanics appear for that word: 60 of 216 Sunday listings were open, 29 of them mobile by name. Its six-day shops numbered 74; 51 left the top 20 and the 23 that stayed fell 5, from 4 to 10, and their 13 Saturday top-three slots became 3. Its 90 five-day shops lost 2 and rose 1, from 12 to 9, with their top-three slots going from 10 to 19. Its 49 seven-day shops lost 10, and the 34 open at Sunday’s minute rose 3, from 9 to 6, with 28 up and 3 down. In the metros, 43 of 58 six-day shops left. The mobile mechanics open at the search sat at a median position of 7 and took 8 of the 11 top-three slots that went to open listings.
Sunday changed the pack about as much as changing the word had the day before: 167 of the 220 Saturday auto repair listings were still in the top 20, 76 percent, against 74 percent kept when “auto repair” became “mechanic.” The churn ran one way. 51 of the 53 shops that left had been open at Saturday’s search; 2 of the 112 that had been closed left. The 52 Sunday entrants were mostly shops closed on Sunday, 38 of 52, at a median position of 16.
Limits
This is one Saturday and one Sunday in 11 cities, 220 and 219 listings, matched by place id, with the second search at the same local hour as the first because the clocks changed between them. A Sunday afternoon search would put the shops that open at 10 or noon into the open group and could move the seven-day result. We did not measure how many people search for auto repair on a Sunday, so we cannot say what a Sunday position is worth in calls. The groups are defined by listed hours and by Google’s open state at one minute, and we did not verify any shop’s actual hours.
Measuring only shops that already rank cannot say what separates them from shops that rank on neither day; the five-day shops that rose had already been strong enough to sit in a pack full of open competitors. One listing was excluded from the Sunday auto repair results and two from the mechanic results, each a national lead marketplace’s own city listing. The mechanic pack carries 11 Sunday entrants with fewer than 30 reviews, several of them keyword-named mobile listings, kept because the groups under test are defined on Saturday’s listings, all read by hand the day before. The metro and small-city figures rest on 6 and 5 cities, and the small-city six-day group is 17 shops. The engine’s forward groups, every Saturday listing crossed with its Sunday hours, were added for this study and recomputed from the saved search with no new searches; the matched counts were identical before and after. Both packs ship as datasets, with Saturday’s rows in yesterday’s.
The data behind this article
Check it yourself.
Every figure above comes from the dataset below, captured . Rows that were screened out of the analysis are included, each with the reason it was excluded, because that screening decision changes findings more often than the analysis does.
Free to reuse with attribution to Ultimate Analytics and a link to this article. If you rerun the analysis and reach a different answer, we would like to know.
Related
For operators
"Tree removal" or "tree service": does Google Maps show the same companies?
Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 192 of 210 tree companies appeared for both words and the top three barely moved. The same word a week apart changed the list almost as much.
For operators
Can a suburb address rank on Google Maps in the city next door? 549 city lists in 25 trades
Listings with an address in another town were 13 percent of Google Maps results and held 4 percent of top-three slots. At the same review count they sat 2 to 7 places lower.
For operators
"Realtor" or "real estate agent": does Google Maps show the same agents?
Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 175 of 217 listings appeared for both words, fewer than the same search repeated 18 days later. Individual agents lost the most.