Talk about a build

For operators 2026-11-12 7 min

"Plumber" or "plumbing": does Google Maps show the same companies?

Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 184 of 212 plumbing companies appeared for both words. The top three barely changed. The bottom half of the list did.

Ultimate Analytics

Most plumbing companies check one search. They type “plumber” and their city, find themselves on the map, and assume the answer holds for “plumbing” too, because the two words mean the same job. Some marketers say the opposite: that every wording is its own contest, and a company has to win each one separately. We searched both words in the same cities, one minute apart, and counted who showed up.

On Thursday, November 12, 2026, a little after 10 in the morning Eastern, we searched Google Maps for “plumber” plus the city in 11 US cities, 6 large metros and 5 small cities. One minute later we searched the same 11 cities for “plumbing.” Each search returned 20 listings, 220 per word. Both packs went through the same screen, which removed supply houses, a union hall, heating companies that do not list plumbing, and two keyword-named listings we could not confirm as businesses. It excluded 8 results from the plumber pack and 9 from the plumbing pack, leaving 212 and 211 companies, matched to each other by Google place id.

The finding

239 distinct companies appeared across the two packs. 184 appeared for both words, 28 only for “plumber” and 27 only for “plumbing.” Put another way, 87 percent of the plumber pack was still there when the word changed.

The top of the list hardly noticed. All 33 companies in a top three for “plumber” were in the pack for “plumbing,” and 27 of the 33 top-three slots went to the same company for both words. The same company held position 1 in 8 of 11 cities. Among companies in both packs, half moved one place or less: 50 held the exact same position, 120 were within two places, and 26 moved five places or more. The rank correlation between the two packs was 0.858.

The turnover was at the bottom. Of the 110 companies in a top ten for “plumber,” 107 reappeared for “plumbing.” Of the 102 at positions 11 to 20, 77 did. The companies that appeared for only one word sat at a median position of 17 in both directions, and none of them was in a top three.

So the belief is mostly right, with a condition. If you are near the top for one word, you are near the top for the other. If you are in the bottom half of the list, one word can show you and the other can leave you out.

For scale: when we ran this design for “auto repair” and “mechanic,” 74 percent of the pack carried over. For “personal injury lawyer” and “attorney,” 94 percent did. Plumbing sits between them.

Your benchmark

Search “plumber” plus your city, then “plumbing” plus your city, within a few minutes of each other. Note your position in each. Then compare with the table.

All 11 cities 6 large metros 5 small cities
Plumber pack still there for “plumbing” 184 of 212 100 of 118 84 of 94
Share 87 percent 85 percent 89 percent
Top-three slots held by the same company 27 of 33 14 of 18 13 of 15
Same company at position 1 8 of 11 4 of 6 4 of 5
In both packs, moved five places or more 26 19 7
Rank correlation between packs 0.858 0.831 0.896

If you hold the same position within two places for both words, you are in the majority. If you appear for one word and not the other and you sit below position 10, that is the ordinary case too. If you are in a top ten for one word and missing for the other, that happened to 3 of 110 companies here, and it is worth a closer look at your listing.

For reference, the top three in the plumbing pack carried a median of 1,563 reviews in the metros and 244 in the small cities. The least reviewed top-three company in each city had a median of 1,047 reviews in metros and 153 in small cities. The median listing in the plumbing pack had 540 reviews in metros and 55 in small cities.

One city did not follow the pattern

The cities were not alike. In Rochester, Minnesota, all 19 companies in the plumber pack reappeared for “plumbing.” In Charlotte and Tampa, 19 of 20 did. In Houston, 12 of 20 did, only one of the three top-three companies was the same, and position 1 changed hands. Nashville kept 14 of 18.

We cannot say why Houston differs. It had a deep field: the plumbing pack there replaced eight companies with eight others, most of them carrying hundreds of reviews. Where more qualified companies compete for twenty slots, a small change in how Google scores the word can swap more of them.

Thin listings churn first

Companies with few reviews were the ones most likely to appear for only one word. Splitting all 239 companies into thirds by review count, 72 percent of the least reviewed third appeared in both packs, against 81 percent of the middle third and 78 percent of the most reviewed third.

In small cities the gap was wider. The least reviewed third there, with a median of 10 reviews, appeared in both packs 59 percent of the time. The middle and top thirds did so 94 and 91 percent of the time. A small-city plumber with a few dozen reviews or more was in both packs almost without exception.

The word in the name did not matter

If the search word favored names that carry it, plumber-named companies would show up more for “plumber.” They did not. Of 17 companies with “plumber” in the name, 14 appeared for both words, 2 only for “plumber” and 1 only for “plumbing.” Of 188 with “plumbing” in the name, 143 appeared for both, 22 only for “plumber” and 23 only for “plumbing.” That is an even split.

Two smaller patterns went the other way, both on counts too small to lean on. Companies with a heating, cooling or air word in the name appeared 7 times only for “plumbing” and 3 times only for “plumber.” And national brands were steady, with 22 of 26 brand locations in both packs, but all 4 that appeared for one word appeared for “plumber,” none for “plumbing” alone.

What verification changed

Our first pass got the comparison wrong, and the reason is useful to anyone who reads a competitor’s listing. Google returned a different first category for the same business depending on the word searched. Among the 184 companies in both packs, 180 came back with Plumber as the first category for the “plumber” search and 168 for the “plumbing” search. The other 12 led with a heating, air conditioning or mechanical contractor category, or with repair service, the second time, with Plumber further down the list.

Our first screen read only the first category. It kept five heating and plumbing companies in the plumber pack and excluded the same five from the plumbing pack, which would have counted them as companies that vanish when the word changes. The second pass keeps any listing that carries the Plumber category anywhere, in both packs. The lesson for an owner: the category shown first on a competitor’s listing in search results is not necessarily the primary category they set.

What to do with it

Check both words, once. If you are in the top ten for one, expect to be in the pack for the other, and treat a miss as a signal. If you are below position 10, do not chase the wording. The companies that held their place for both words were the ones with more reviews, and renaming a listing to carry the other word showed no benefit here.

Limits

This is one morning in 11 cities, and it measures who appears, not who gets the call. We do not have a same-word baseline for plumbers, so we cannot say how much of the 13 percent turnover is the word and how much is the ordinary difference between any two searches a minute apart; in the lawyer study, the same word nine days apart moved the list about as much as the synonym did. We captured only the top 20, so a company missing from one pack may sit just outside it. Searches were not run from a device inside each city, and results on a phone near the customer will differ. The Houston result is one city and may not repeat. The review-third and name-word comparisons are counts, not tests, and several rest on fewer than 30 companies. Two words are not every wording: “plumber near me” and “emergency plumber” were not searched. Every listing, including the excluded ones with their reasons, is in the dataset.

The data behind this article

Check it yourself.

Every figure above comes from the dataset below, captured . Rows that were screened out of the analysis are included, each with the reason it was excluded, because that screening decision changes findings more often than the analysis does.

Free to reuse with attribution to Ultimate Analytics and a link to this article. If you rerun the analysis and reach a different answer, we would like to know.

Find out what your marketing
is actually achieving.

One conversation, no obligation: what you sell, who you lose deals to, and what you cannot currently see. If a build is a fit, it is scoped and quoted from there. There is no signup and no self-serve tier.

No prices on this site. Every engagement is scoped and quoted after the first meeting.