How many Google reviews does a tree service need? We read 400 Maps listings in 22 cities
The least reviewed tree service in a typical Google Maps top three has 63 reviews, and below the top three the review ladder is flat. What the top three share is an address in the city searched: 61 of 66.
Tree service owners tend to hold two beliefs about the Google map pack. The first is that it belongs to the companies with hundreds of reviews and a national name on the truck. The second follows from it: a crew that works from a home address in the next town over cannot get into the top three, so there is little point in trying.
We measured both. On the morning of Friday, November 13, 2026 we captured the Google Maps top 20 for “tree service” in 22 US cities, 11 large metros and 11 small cities, and read every listing: 435 results, 400 tree service companies after screening, 22 searches.
The first belief is mostly wrong: the review bar is lower than owners expect, and the national brands hold few of the top slots. The second is half right: the top three is close to a list of companies with an address inside the city that was searched.
The number to write down first
The median tree service in the list has 67 reviews. The median company in the top three has 132. Below the top three, the ladder is flat.
| Maps position | Listings | Median reviews | Address in the city searched | Median miles from the city center |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 to 3 | 66 | 132 | 92 percent | 4.7 |
| 4 to 7 | 83 | 59 | 78 percent | 6.4 |
| 8 to 12 | 101 | 56 | 57 percent | 6.2 |
| 13 to 20 | 150 | 58 | 52 percent | 8.2 |
What changes down the list is the address column, not the review column.
The question an owner has is what the thinnest winner carries. So for each city we took the least reviewed company in its top three. Market size moves that floor.
| Large metros | Small cities | |
|---|---|---|
| Median listing | 118 reviews | 22 reviews |
| Median top three listing | 218 reviews | 68 reviews |
| Median least reviewed company in the top three | 134 reviews | 52 reviews |
| Cities with a top three company under 50 reviews | 3 of 11 | 5 of 11 |
| Top three listings under 100 reviews | 4 of 33 | 23 of 33 |
Here is the benchmark. Search “tree service” plus your city and read the three review counts at the top. Take the lowest. Across all 22 cities the median of that number was 63, and in 13 of 22 cities it was under 100. In a metro, expect something near 134. In a small city, near 52. The highest floor in the sample was 210.
The company with the most reviews in its city held position 1 in 5 of the 22 cities. Review count and position were related, but weakly: a rank correlation of -0.182 across the sample, -0.203 in metros and -0.35 in small cities. Star rating did not order the list at all (0.023). The median rating was 4.9 in every position band.
The national brands hold 5 of 66 top three slots
Four national tree care brands appeared: Davey in 9 cities with 11 offices, Bartlett with 4, SavATree with 3 and Monster Tree Service with 2. Together they were 20 of the 400 listings, 5 percent, and held 5 of the 66 top three slots and position 1 in 3 of 22 cities. One brand accounts for 4 of those 5 slots and all 3 first positions.
In the small cities, 3 of 183 listings were a brand office. Brand offices carried more reviews than independents (a median of 132 against 64), and when companies with similar review counts were compared, none of the three review thirds showed a significant difference in position.
An independent tree service is competing with other independents: 380 of 400 listings and 61 of 66 top three slots.
What the top three share is the address
Every listing shows either a street address or none. We sorted the 400 into three groups: an address in the city searched (262 listings, 66 percent), an address in another town (71, 18 percent), and no address shown (67, 17 percent).
Of the 66 top three listings, 61 had an address in the city searched. One had an address in another town. Four showed no address. Position 1 went to a company with an address in the city in 22 of 22 cities.
This is not reviews in disguise. Companies in another town carried as many reviews as companies in the city, a median of 76 against 73, and sat at a median position of 13 against 8. In the metros the out-of-town companies carried nearly twice the reviews, 210 against 113, and sat at 14 against 9. One of those 39 was in a top three.
Holding review count roughly constant makes it sharper. We split the sample into thirds by review count. In the least reviewed third, in-city and out-of-town companies sat close together (10 against 12, not a significant difference). In the middle third it was 7 against 15, and in the most reviewed third 6 against 14, both significant. Among metro companies with 160 or more reviews, in-city listings sat at a median position of 4 and out-of-town listings at 14.
Reviews, in other words, pay off for the company whose address is in the city.
Distance inside the city mattered less than the city line. Top three companies with a street address sat a median 4.7 miles from the center and none was farther than 15 miles, but the correlation between position and miles was modest (0.227).
In small cities, a third of the list hides its address
Tree work is done at the customer’s property, so many owners list a service area and hide the address. In the metros 11 of 217 did (5 percent). In the small cities 56 of 183 did (31 percent), and that is where it showed.
Small-city listings with no address held 2 of 33 top three slots and made up 46 percent of positions 13 to 20. They were not thinner listings: their median review count was 29, against 20 for small-city companies with an in-city address. Among small-city companies with 45 or more reviews, those showing an in-city address sat at a median position of 2 and those hiding the address at 12.
In the metros the 11 hidden-address listings showed no such gap, which is too few to conclude anything from.
What the screen caught
We excluded 35 of the 435 results, 32 of them in small cities, and read every row to do it.
Twelve were lawn care or landscaping companies by name that list tree service as one of several categories. Nine were listings we could not confirm as a tree company: a name made only of the city and the trade with two reviews or fewer, or a site that turned out to be a referral page or showed only a toll-free number. The rest were Christmas tree farms, nurseries, garden centers, a firewood seller, land clearing and construction contractors and two more landscapers. In one small city, 11 of 20 results were not tree companies, and position 1 there went to a keyword-named listing with 6 reviews, which we kept because we could not show it was not a business.
The read also corrected us. Our first rule dropped any name containing the word firewood, which removed two real Detroit tree companies that also sell it. One of them sat at position 2 with 347 reviews and an address in a neighboring city. Restoring it turned “no out-of-town company in any top three” into one. The floors did not move.
Six times, one company held two listings in the same city at two addresses. Each is counted as its own listing, because each takes a slot.
Limits
What was measured: the Google Maps top 20 for one query, “tree service” plus the city, captured once on a Friday morning shortly after 9 Eastern, from one location setting per market. Review counts, ratings and addresses are as Google displayed them at that moment. Distance is measured to one geocoded center point per city, using street addresses only. Seven listings showed no review count and are left out of every review median; none was in a top three.
What was not measured: searches for “tree removal”, “tree trimming” or “arborist”, which may return a different list; a search made from a specific street, where the searcher’s own location would enter; emergency searches after a storm; and anything about the companies’ websites, licensing or insurance.
What else could explain it: every company here already ranks in the top 20, so this study describes what separates positions inside the list, not what keeps a company off it. An in-city address may stand in for something else, such as a yard, an office and a longer local history. A hidden address mixes companies based in the city with companies based outside it, and we cannot see whether showing one would move the listing. The small-city thirds hold 58 or 59 listings each, so the size of those gaps is uncertain even where the direction is clear. A weak review correlation is not evidence that reviews do nothing: the top three carried more than twice the reviews of everyone else, and the sample cannot detect small effects below that.
The data behind this article
Check it yourself.
Every figure above comes from the dataset below, captured . Rows that were screened out of the analysis are included, each with the reason it was excluded, because that screening decision changes findings more often than the analysis does.
Free to reuse with attribution to Ultimate Analytics and a link to this article. If you rerun the analysis and reach a different answer, we would like to know.
Related
Measurement
How many Google reviews does a house painter need? We read 396 Maps listings in 22 cities
The least reviewed painter in a typical metro Google Maps top three has 164 reviews; in a typical small city, 14. Painting franchises held 10 of 66 top three slots.
Measurement
How many Google reviews does a landscaping company need? We read 399 Maps listings in 22 cities
The least reviewed landscaper in a typical small-city Google Maps top three has 26 reviews, and in a metro 59. The national lawn brands held 1 of 66 top three slots, and lawn care companies held 1 more.
Measurement
Do Google reviews matter for a managed IT provider? We read 362 Maps listings in 22 cities
The median managed IT provider in a Google Maps top 20 has 24 reviews, and 6 of 66 top three listings show none. Review count barely orders the list. The office address does.