Talk about a build

For operators 2026-11-14 8 min

Do you need a website to rank on Google Maps? 483 city lists in 22 trades

Google Maps listings with no website are 11 percent of the top 20 and 6 percent of top-three slots. At the same review count they sit about where listings with a site do.

Ultimate Analytics

Ask how to get a small business onto Google Maps and the first answer is usually the same: build a website, because a Google Business Profile without one cannot compete. Owners who run on phone calls and word of mouth hear that a site is the price of entry to the map pack.

One earlier study in this series tested it on a single trade. Among handymen, listings without a website of their own were common in the top three, and the apparent penalty disappeared once review count was held roughly constant. One trade is not enough to change anyone’s mind, so we asked the question of every list the series has captured on one set of 22 US cities: twenty-two trades and professions, 11 large metros and 11 small cities, captured between late September and November 13, 2026. That is 483 trade-by-city lists and 8,499 listings after each source study’s screen (910 excluded results stay in the dataset with their reasons). No new searches were run.

The short answer: the belief describes the list but not the cause. Listings with no website do sit lower, and they are rare at the top. But they also carry far fewer reviews, and at the same review count they sit within about a place of listings that have a site.

Your benchmark

Across all 22 trades, 905 listings (11 percent) had no website link at all. Another 220 (3 percent) linked to a page that is not their own: a booking platform, a social profile or a directory. The rest, 87 percent, linked to a site of their own.

Market size moves this more than anything else. In the 11 metros, 94 percent of listings had their own site and 5 percent had none. In the 11 small cities, 78 percent had their own site and 17 percent had none.

Listings with no website held 86 of 1,415 top-three slots, which is 6 percent, and position 1 in 16 of 478 lists. In metros that was 25 of 717 top-three slots (3 percent) and 2 first positions. In small cities it was 61 of 698 (9 percent) and 14 first positions. A listing with no website was in the top three in 76 of the 483 lists.

So the strong version of the belief is wrong: a listing with no website can reach the top three, and in about one list in six one did. The weak version, that the top of the list is mostly businesses with sites, is true in every trade.

Find your trade

Trade Listings with no website Metros Small cities Top-three slots they hold First positions
Handyman 30% 17% 44% 16 of 65 3 of 21
Appliance repair 22% 17% 31% 8 of 65 1 of 22
Pet groomers 17% 11% 24% 9 of 66 3 of 22
Accountants 15% 8% 22% 5 of 66 1 of 22
Tree service 15% 10% 21% 6 of 66 0 of 22
House cleaning 13% 2% 28% 2 of 63 1 of 21
Moving 13% 1% 32% 4 of 65 0 of 22
Hair salons 13% 5% 22% 2 of 66 1 of 22
Carpet cleaning 10% 6% 17% 1 of 64 0 of 22
Locksmiths 10% 6% 25% 7 of 62 0 of 22
Junk removal 10% 3% 24% 3 of 52 2 of 20
Roofing 9% 3% 15% 3 of 66 1 of 22
Pest control 9% 5% 14% 3 of 65 0 of 22
Chiropractors 9% 3% 15% 1 of 66 0 of 22
Garage door repair 8% 4% 16% 4 of 66 0 of 22
HVAC 6% 2% 10% 1 of 66 0 of 22
Insurance agencies 5% 5% 6% 3 of 57 0 of 20
Real estate agents 5% 1% 8% 2 of 66 1 of 22
Physical therapy 4% 0% 8% 1 of 65 0 of 22
Managed IT services 4% 1% 8% 4 of 66 2 of 22
Dentists 3% 2% 4% 1 of 66 0 of 22
Personal injury lawyers 3% 0% 6% 0 of 66 0 of 22

To place yourself, search your trade and your city, open the top 20, and count the listings with no Website button. Then count how many of them are in the top three.

Why the list looks like it punishes no website

Down the list, the share without a site climbs: 6 percent of positions 1 to 3, 8 percent of positions 4 to 7, 11 percent of positions 8 to 12 and 14 percent of positions 13 to 20. In small cities the climb is steeper: 9, 14, 19 and 23 percent. The median listing with no website sits at position 12, against 10 for a listing with its own site.

The reviews explain most of that. A listing with its own site carries a median 119 reviews. A listing with no website carries a median 16. In all 22 trades the no-website listings carried significantly fewer reviews, and review count is what orders these lists. So the fair comparison is between listings with similar review counts.

Same reviews, same place

We split each trade’s listings into thirds by review count, then compared the median position of listings with their own site and listings with no website inside each third.

Median position Own website No website
Least reviewed third 12 13
Middle third 10 11
Most reviewed third 7 6
Small cities, least reviewed third 12 13
Small cities, most reviewed third 5 6
Metros, least reviewed third 13 14
Metros, most reviewed third 7 4

The gap is one place or less in every row, and in the most reviewed third the listings without a site sit slightly higher. Only the least reviewed third shows a statistically significant difference, and it is tiny (a rank correlation of 0.048). The middle and most reviewed thirds show no difference this sample can detect (0.017 and -0.003), on 2,769 and 2,792 listings.

Trade by trade, the pooled comparison favored listings with a site in 11 of 22 trades and the reverse in none. Inside review thirds it was 6 of 55 tests favoring a site and 2 favoring no site. That is close to what chance alone would produce.

Two further checks pointed the same way. On listings with at least 10 reviews, the thirds read 11 against 12, 9 against 9 and 7 against 5. On listings whose address is in the city searched, they read 11 against 12, 9 against 8 and 6 against 6.

What verification found

The website button is not always the business’s website. Reading every host that more than one listing linked, and every host on an unusual web address, turned up a template network in one trade: 13 pet groomer listings linked to sites named for the business whose page titles ended in a network’s name rather than the business’s alone. Seven more salon and groomer listings linked to directory profile or appointment pages, three linked to a city guide’s places pages, and one to a scheduling link. We reclassified all 24 as third-party pages and re-ran the study at no cost. The no-website group did not change, and neither did any finding above; the own-site share for pet groomers fell from 67 to 63 percent. If your profile links to a page you did not build, check who owns it.

What to do with this

  • If you have no website and a thin review count, the website is not what is holding you back on Maps in this data. The review count is.
  • If you are in a metro, 94 percent of the listings you compete with have a site. The site will not move you up the map, but a customer comparing you with the listing above may expect one.
  • If you are in a small city and in a trade near the top of the table, a listing with no website in your own top three is common. Count yours before deciding a site is the problem.
  • A website still does work the map pack cannot measure: it answers questions, shows prices and services, and gives Google something to read for organic search. This study measures only position on the map.

Limits

  • Twenty-two snapshots, taken on twenty-two different days at different hours between late September and November 13, 2026. The lists are not one moment.
  • Only businesses already in the top 20 are measured. A website may help a business get onto the list in the first place, and nothing here can say.
  • Websites and reviews travel together. A site may be how some businesses earn their reviews, so holding reviews constant may hide part of a real effect of having one. The data cannot separate the two.
  • A listing with no website link is read as a business with no site. Some may have a site they never added to the profile.
  • The 169 listings with no review count, 76 of them without a website, fall outside the review-third comparison.
  • Every search named the city and ran from a server. A search from a phone near the business may behave differently.
  • The chain tag and the exclusion screen are each source study’s own, and are not uniform across trades.
  • This is correlation in one set of 22 cities. Businesses without a website may differ in ways we did not measure.

The data behind this article

Check it yourself.

Every figure above comes from the dataset below, captured . Rows that were screened out of the analysis are included, each with the reason it was excluded, because that screening decision changes findings more often than the analysis does.

Free to reuse with attribution to Ultimate Analytics and a link to this article. If you rerun the analysis and reach a different answer, we would like to know.

Find out what your marketing
is actually achieving.

One conversation, no obligation: what you sell, who you lose deals to, and what you cannot currently see. If a build is a fit, it is scoped and quoted from there. There is no signup and no self-serve tier.

No prices on this site. Every engagement is scoped and quoted after the first meeting.