What star rating does an appliance repair shop need for the Google Maps top three? 359 listings in 22 cities
In 22 cities, 13 of 65 Google Maps top-three slots for appliance repair went to a listing rated under 4.5. Review count sorted the list; the star rating did not.
Appliance repair owners hear one rule about Google Maps more than any other: the star rating is the whole game. Slip below about 4.8, or take a run of one-star reviews from customers whose part was back-ordered, and the listing drops out of the top three. The winners, the story goes, show a perfect 5.0.
We tested that against the list itself. On Friday, November 6, 2026, at about 9:10 in the morning Eastern, we captured the Google Maps top 20 for “appliance repair” in 22 US cities, 11 large metros and 11 small cities. We saw 407 results (several small cities returned fewer than 20) and excluded 46 with their reason: 19 heating and cooling contractors, 6 parts suppliers, 6 vacuum and sewing machine shops, 3 appliance stores, 3 general repair listings with no appliance category or name, and 9 others, from a television repair shop to a mobile mechanic. That left 359 appliance repair businesses, 348 of them showing a star rating.
The belief does not survive the list. The median listing is rated 4.8, the median top-three listing is rated 4.8, and so is the median listing at positions 13 to 20. Of the 65 top-three slots, 13 (20 percent) went to a listing rated under 4.5, and only 8 (12 percent) went to a perfect 5.0. Held against review count, rating told us nothing about position at all. What did sort the list was the number of reviews and, in small cities, how close the shop sits to the middle of town.
Your benchmark
Search “appliance repair” and your city in Google Maps and read the three ratings at the top. Here is what the 22 cities showed.
- The lowest rating in each city’s top three had a median of 4.6. In the 11 metros it was 4.7, ranging from 4.3 to 4.9; in the 11 small cities it was 4.3, ranging from 2.8 to 4.8.
- 9 of 22 cities had a top-three listing under 4.5: 2 of the 11 metros and 7 of the 11 small cities. 12 of 22 had one under 4.7.
- Position 1 was rated under 4.8 in 6 of 22 cities and was a perfect 5.0 in just one, a listing with 24 reviews.
- Review count is the thing that moved. The top three carried a median of 200 reviews against 48 at positions 13 to 20. In metros it was 548 against 52; in small cities, 60 against 28.
If your rating is at or above the lowest one in your city’s top three, the rating is probably not what is holding you back. Count the reviews instead.
A perfect 5.0 lives at the bottom of the list
Of the 348 rated listings, 82 (24 percent) showed a perfect 5.0. Those listings carried a median of just 7 reviews, 72 percent of them had fewer than 50, and their median position was 13. A perfect rating is what a new or thinly reviewed listing looks like. A perfect 5.0 took 12 percent of the top-three slots and 34 percent of positions 13 to 20. Only 10 percent of perfect-rated listings reached a top three, against 24 percent of listings rated 4.8 to 4.9 and 21 percent of those rated 4.5 to 4.7.
| Rating | Listings | Median reviews | Median position | In a top three |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.0 | 82 | 7 | 13 | 8 |
| 4.8 to 4.9 | 115 | 211 | 7 | 28 |
| 4.5 to 4.7 | 75 | 96 | 8 | 16 |
| Below 4.5 | 76 | 45 | 9 | 13 |
Read the table by its middle column: the 4.8 to 4.9 group does best, but it also carries the most reviews by far. Ratings and review counts move slightly against each other here (rho -0.11): one plain reading is that the more customers a shop has served, the more likely one of them was unhappy, which pulls the average off 5.0.
Rating, held to equal reviews
Because rating and review count travel together, a fair test of the rating has to hold reviews still. The engine split the rated listings into three equal groups by review count (1 to 39, 39 to 186, and 191 or more) and asked, inside each group, whether a higher rating went with a better position.
It did not, in any of the three. The rank correlations were 0.042, -0.02 and 0.069, all too small to tell apart from zero. Across the whole sample the figure was 0.052, and it was -0.01 in metros and 0.041 in small cities. Review count, measured the same way, correlated with position at -0.302 across the sample (more reviews, higher on the list) and at -0.406 in metros.
“Not significant” is not “no effect.” This sample cannot rule out a small effect, and it says little about a 3-star average. It does say that across the 4.5 to 5.0 range where three quarters of shops sit, a tenth of a star is not what separates the top three from the rest.
Small cities are where low ratings reach the top
The 11 small cities had a median rating of 4.6 against 4.9 in metros, and seven of their top threes held a listing under 4.5. They also had fewer real choices: when a city returns nine or twelve listings, the top three can include whoever is close and established, whatever the stars say.
Distance mattered there in a way it did not in metros. In small cities the correlation between position and distance from the city center was 0.448; in metros it was 0.106, too weak to call. Across all 22 cities, the median top-three listing sat 3.3 miles from center against 7.9 miles at positions 13 to 20.
The brands
Franchise, national and multi-city brands (any operator with listings in three or more of our cities, or two in one) were 28 of the 359 listings (8 percent) and held 10 of the 65 top-three slots. Mr. Appliance appeared in 14 of our 22 cities and Sears Home Services in 9. Brand locations carried a median rating of 4.7, a shade under independents at 4.8, and a median of 290 reviews against 68. They reach the top three on review volume, not on stars, which is the same lesson from a different angle.
What verification changed
The first pass kept 374 businesses, and reading every row outside the appliance repair categories found 15 that were not appliance repair shops at all: a mobile auto mechanic, a television repair shop, a sewing shop, a handyman, an electronics parts supplier, a corporate office with one 1-star review (the lowest rating in that first pass), three general repair listings with no appliance category or name, a refrigeration contractor, and five heating and cooling contractors kept only because a refrigerator repair category sat among their secondary categories. We tightened the screen and re-ran the saved results at no cost.
The headline did not move. The top-three figures (13 slots under 4.5, 8 at 5.0, median 4.8) were identical in both runs, and the overall rating correlation went from 0.031 to 0.052, still nothing. The run that ships is the second.
We also kept 11 listings with no rating at all, most with a keyword name (“appliance repair” plus a city) and no reviews. They are counted as unrated, never as zero.
Limits: what this can and cannot tell you
- One search, one morning. These are 22 searches on a Friday around 9 AM Eastern, from Google’s default location for each city. A searcher on the far side of town sees a different list.
- Ranking businesses only. Every listing here already made the top 20. The study cannot say what a 3.0 rating does to a shop that is not on the list, or whether a shop that falls from 4.8 to 4.2 loses its place. It shows that shops at 4.2 hold top-three slots, not that their rating did not cost them.
- The rating shown is rounded. Google displays one decimal. A 4.8 can be anything from 4.75 to 4.84, so finer distinctions are invisible.
- Thin small-city lists. Wausau returned 3 listings, Lawton 9 and Abilene 12. Small-city figures rest on fewer shops per city and should be read as a direction, not a precise level.
- What else could explain it. Review count, distance, years on Google, categories and review replies all travel with rating; we measured the first two. And a rating may still matter to the customer who reads it, which this study does not measure.
The number to write down
The lowest star rating in your city’s top three, and the review count of the listing that holds it. In 12 of our 22 cities that rating was 4.6 or lower. If yours is above it, spend the next month asking for reviews, not worrying about the tenth of a star.
The data behind this article
Check it yourself.
Every figure above comes from the dataset below, captured . Rows that were screened out of the analysis are included, each with the reason it was excluded, because that screening decision changes findings more often than the analysis does.
Free to reuse with attribution to Ultimate Analytics and a link to this article. If you rerun the analysis and reach a different answer, we would like to know.
Related
For operators
"Tree removal" or "tree service": does Google Maps show the same companies?
Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 192 of 210 tree companies appeared for both words and the top three barely moved. The same word a week apart changed the list almost as much.
For operators
Can a suburb address rank on Google Maps in the city next door? 549 city lists in 25 trades
Listings with an address in another town were 13 percent of Google Maps results and held 4 percent of top-three slots. At the same review count they sat 2 to 7 places lower.
For operators
"Realtor" or "real estate agent": does Google Maps show the same agents?
Searched one minute apart in 11 US cities, 175 of 217 listings appeared for both words, fewer than the same search repeated 18 days later. Individual agents lost the most.