Talk about a build

For operators 2026-11-08 7 min

What star rating do you need for the Google Maps top three? 418 city lists in nineteen trades

Ratings on 7,323 Google Maps listings in nineteen trades and 22 cities: the lowest rating that still made a top three had a median of 4.7, and above it rating did not sort the list.

Ultimate Analytics

Ask a local business owner what it takes to reach the Google Maps top three and the star rating usually comes up first. The belief has a few versions: drop under about 4.8 and you fall out, under 4.5 you are invisible, and the businesses on top show a perfect 5.0. We tested it on every list the series has captured on one set of 22 US cities. Nineteen trades and professions, the same 11 large metros and 11 small cities, captured on nineteen days between September 29 and November 7, 2026: roofing, house cleaning, garage door repair, carpet cleaning, locksmiths, dentists, moving, hair salons, physical therapy, HVAC, pest control, accountants, insurance agencies, personal injury lawyers, chiropractors, real estate agents, pet groomers, appliance repair and handyman. That is 8,124 results, 7,447 businesses after each study’s own exclusions, 7,323 of them rated, in 418 trade-by-city lists. No new searches were spent; every rating comes from a dataset already published.

The short answer: the rating sets a floor, and the floor is lower than owners think. Above it, the rating did not sort the list. Across all 7,323 rated listings, the rank correlation between position and rating was 0.021, which is no relationship at all, while review count was -0.244 and significant in all 19 trades.

Your benchmark

The median rating is useless as a target, because it is 4.9 at every position: 4.9 in the top three, 4.9 at positions 4 to 7, 4.9 at 8 to 12 and 4.9 at 13 to 20. The number that tells you whether your rating can compete is the lowest rating that still made your city’s top three.

Across the 418 lists, that floor had a median of 4.7. In large metros it was 4.8, in small cities 4.7. In 222 of the 418 lists (53 percent) at least one top-three business was rated under 4.8, and in 78 (19 percent) one was rated under 4.5: 23 of 209 metro lists and 55 of 209 small-city lists. Even under 4.0 happened, in 17 lists.

To run it on your own market, search your trade and city in Google Maps, read the ratings of the three businesses on top, and take the lowest. If yours is at or above it, your rating is not what is keeping you out.

Find your trade

Trade Lowest top-three rating, median city Metros Small cities Top-three slots under 4.5 Share of listings at 5.0 Rank vs rating
Carpet cleaning 4.9 4.9 4.7 3 of 64 35% 0.067
Chiropractors 4.9 4.9 4.9 0 of 66 48% 0.047
Roofing 4.8 4.7 4.8 2 of 66 34% 0.01
Garage door repair 4.8 4.8 4.7 4 of 66 39% 0.071
Dentists 4.8 4.7 4.8 1 of 66 16% -0.048
Physical therapy 4.8 4.8 4.8 1 of 65 52% -0.034
HVAC 4.8 4.8 4.7 2 of 66 17% 0.032
Insurance agencies 4.8 4.8 4.6 7 of 57 21% -0.039
Personal injury lawyers 4.8 4.8 4.8 0 of 66 26% -0.131
Real estate agents 4.8 4.9 4.6 6 of 66 49% 0.003
House cleaning 4.7 4.7 4.5 7 of 62 31% 0.068
Hair salons 4.7 4.8 4.7 4 of 66 12% 0
Pest control 4.7 4.7 4.7 2 of 65 23% 0.029
Locksmiths 4.6 4.7 4.5 7 of 62 20% 0.003
Moving 4.6 4.6 4.4 8 of 65 20% -0.009
Accountants 4.6 4.7 4.4 13 of 66 42% 0.077
Pet groomers 4.6 4.6 4.6 6 of 66 20% -0.019
Appliance repair 4.6 4.7 4.3 13 of 65 24% 0.052
Handyman 4.5 4.7 4.4 12 of 63 43% 0.17

A negative rank correlation would mean higher-rated listings sit higher. Only 2 of the 19 trades showed a significant one, and they pointed in opposite directions: personal injury lawyers (-0.131, favoring the higher rating) and handyman (0.17, favoring the lower one, because a perfect handyman rating is usually a new listing with a handful of reviews).

The trade matters more than the market. Chiropractors and carpet cleaners leave almost no room under 4.9, while in small-city appliance repair the median floor was 4.3 and 11 of 32 top-three slots went to listings under 4.5.

What a perfect 5.0 is really measuring

30 percent of rated listings (2,220) showed a perfect 5.0. If a perfect score won, they would crowd the top. They did the opposite: 5.0 listings were 22 percent of top-three listings and 34 percent of positions 13 to 20. Their median position was 11 and their median review count 45; 526 had fewer than 10 reviews and 139 had exactly one.

The listings that held the top were rated a little under perfect and reviewed a lot. The 2,998 listings at 4.8 or 4.9 carried a median of 203 reviews and took 635 of the 1,228 top-three slots, 52 percent. Listings rated 4.5 to 4.7 took 222, and those under 4.5 took 98, 8 percent of the slots, with a median of 29 reviews.

The clearest single test: position 1 was the best-rated listing in its own list (ties included) in only 85 of 414 lists.

Holding review count constant

Ratings and reviews are tangled, so we compared listings with similar review counts. All 7,323 were split into thirds: 1 to 46 reviews, 46 to 216, and 216 to 36,773. Inside those thirds the rank correlation with rating was 0.037, 0.027 and -0.047. The last one clears the significance bar only because the third holds 2,441 listings; a correlation that small moves nobody.

Trade by trade it was the same. Within each trade’s own review thirds, 5 of 57 tests were significant and only 1 favored the higher rating. Split by market size the tests got noisier but no more consistent: in metros 7 of 57 were significant, 3 favoring the higher rating; in small cities 14 of 57, 8 favoring the higher rating and 6 the lower. The one place a higher rating won in more than one review third was small-city personal injury lawyers (-0.433 for firms with 24 to 59 reviews, -0.289 for 60 to 1,980).

Not significant does not mean the rating never matters. It means that in samples this size, a higher rating above the floor bought no position that review volume did not already explain.

What to do with this

  • Find your floor. Read your city’s top three, take the lowest rating, and compare yours. If you are at or above it, stop treating the rating as the problem.
  • If you are below it, the rating is worth fixing, and the fix is the same as for volume: more reviews from recent, real customers, which raise both.
  • Do not chase a perfect 5.0. It mostly marks a listing with few reviews, and those sit low.
  • Put your effort into volume. Review count ordered the list in all 19 trades (rank correlations from -0.154 to -0.408).

Limits

  • Nineteen snapshots, taken on nineteen different days between September 29 and November 7, 2026, at different hours. The lists are not one moment.
  • Only businesses already in the top 20 are measured. A very low rating may keep a business off the list entirely, and nothing here can say. The 795 listings under 4.5 that did make a list sat at a median position of 11.
  • Ratings are the one-decimal figure Google showed. Two listings shown at 4.8 can differ in their underlying average.
  • Each trade was searched once per city with its main phrase, from a server, not a phone.
  • The chain and organization tag and the exclusion screen are each source study’s own, and are not uniform across trades.
  • We measured position, not calls. A higher rating may still win more of the customers who see the list, which this study does not measure.
  • As a check that the roll-up reads the right data, the appliance repair figures reproduce that study’s published floor (median 4.6; metros 4.7, small cities 4.3) and its 13 of 65 top-three slots under 4.5 exactly.

The data behind this article

Check it yourself.

Every figure above comes from the dataset below, captured . Rows that were screened out of the analysis are included, each with the reason it was excluded, because that screening decision changes findings more often than the analysis does.

Free to reuse with attribution to Ultimate Analytics and a link to this article. If you rerun the analysis and reach a different answer, we would like to know.

Find out what your marketing
is actually achieving.

One conversation, no obligation: what you sell, who you lose deals to, and what you cannot currently see. If a build is a fit, it is scoped and quoted from there. There is no signup and no self-serve tier.

No prices on this site. Every engagement is scoped and quoted after the first meeting.